Panel Submission Information

ACM Policy : Prior Publication and Simultaneous Submissions

Under no circumstances shall a paper (or substantially the same paper) be simultaneously submitted to two or more publications, or to a second publication while still under review elsewhere, without a letter of notification to the Editor-in-Chief (EiC) or Program Chair (PC) of each affected publication. Failure to adhere to this policy is cause for rejection of the manuscript. Repeated violations may lead to a ban on future submissions at the discretion of the EiC or PC.”

The ACM website has the full policy.

Author Guidelines: Panel Session

Panel sessions provide an opportunity for expert panel members to present their views on a specific topic and then to discuss these views among themselves and with the audience. Usually, a panel session starts with a brief introduction of the panel topic and the participants, followed by short presentations by the panelists giving their views. They are scheduled in standard conference spaces. The session must allow sufficient opportunity (about 30 minutes) for an interactive question and answer period involving both the panelists and the audience.

A typical panel will consist of four participants, including the moderator. Limiting a panel to four participants allows sufficient time for audience questions. Proposals with more than four panelists must convincingly show that all panelists will be able to speak, and the audience able to respond, within the session time.

Single-Anonymous Review Process

Initial submissions to the Panels track are reviewed with the single-anonymous review process, where the submissions are not anonymized but reviewers are anonymous to each other and to the authors. During the discussion of a submission in EasyChair, reviewers can refer to each other by their reviewer number on that submission’s review.

Criteria used in reviewing the proposals include the likely level of interest of the topic, the presence of panel members with multiple perspectives on the topic and significant expertise and experience, and the likelihood that the panel will leave sufficient time for audience participation.

If the proposal is accepted, all presenters listed in the panel description will be required to register for the conference and to participate in the session.

Planning for a virtual session

The SIGCSE 2021 Technical Symposium will be virtual. We believe that panels can be conducted productively in this virtual format, but proposers will need to explicitly plan their session to be successful in this format. Panels should need relatively few changes from their in-person setting, but a strong plan for moderating questions from the audience productively in a virtual setting will be necessary. You must include in your proposal details of how the panel will be run in virtual format. Please do not refer to specific technologies. Instead focus on the process that you will use to make sure remote panelists and participants are engaged and included.

Resubmitting an accepted Panel from 2020

Normally repeat submission of the same Panel in back-to-back years is discouraged, but because the 2020 Technical Symposium was canceled, it is fine to resubmit an accepted Panel from 2020 for consideration for the 2021 Technical Symposium. However, please take note of the following:

1. You must have a clear plan for a virtual format in your submission.
2. You should clearly indicate in your submission that this is a resubmission of an accepted panel from 2020.
3. If accepted, the abstract will not be republished, but your panel will run in the 2021 Symposium.
4. There is no guarantee that a panel will be accepted this year just because it was accepted last year. Having it accepted last year will not hurt or improve the chances that it is accepted this year.

How Should The Proposal Be Formatted?

The proposal is limited to a maximum of and must adhere to ACM’s publication guidelines:

Be sure to use US letter size pages that measure 8.5” by 11”, that’s 215.9mm by 279.4mm.

SIGCSE 2021 is not participating in the new ACM workflow, template, and production system. Word Authors, please use the Interim Template. LaTeX Authors, please use the official ACM Master with the ACM_SigConf template.

The following modifications and exceptions do apply:

• When providing author information, indicate which of the panelists is the moderator by placing the word “Moderator” in parentheses after their name.

• Abstract: Should provide a brief summary of your panel.

• Summary: The first section should be titled Summary and should provide an expanded summary of the panel’s goals, intended audience, and relevance to the SIGCSE community written by the moderator. If this is a resubmission of a panel that was accepted for the 2020 Symposium, please indicate this.

• Panel Structure: The section following the summary should explain the panel structure and plan for audience participation and provide sufficient time for audience interaction and questions. NEW for 2021, this section should explicitly describe how a virtual panel will be structured and run.

• Position Statements: The subsequent sections should contain the position statements of each panelist and a brief description of their expertise and background as it relates to the panel. Title each section by identifying the panelist.

• References: Citing relevant work where appropriate is encouraged, but not required. If they are included, they should be placed in a separate section titled References and should follow the formatting guidelines.

If accepted, the panel description will be allocated in the conference proceedings and must adhere to the formatting guidelines specified above. To facilitate the transition from proposal to camera-ready copy, it is critical that authors adhere closely to the formatting specifications and page limits.

Sample Proposal

• Sample proposal (PDF) *
• Sample proposal (Word) *

* NOTE: This sample does not include information about a virtual format, which is required this year.

How Do I Submit My Panel?

SIGCSE TS 2021 is not participating in the new ACM workflow, template, and production system. MS Word Authors, please use the Interim Template. LaTeX Authors, please use the official ACM Master with the ACM_SigConf template.

Submissions use the English language. If you desire editing services, consider the following from the ACM.

ACM has partnered with International Science Editing (ISE) to provide language editing services to ACM authors. ISE offers a comprehensive range of services for authors including standard and premium English language editing, as well as illustration and translation services. Editing services are at author expense and do not guarantee publication of a manuscript.

• Write your submission using the format specified above. Within the proposal, you must provide Category and Subject Descriptors, General Terms, and Keywords, just as paper authors must do. These requirements are described in more detail in the ACM Computing Classification System.

• Recall that you will also need to copy-and-paste or type your text abstract description into a text box in the submission form. Be sure that the same text appears in the submission and in the abstract text box in the submission form.

• Be sure to choose the appropriate topic areas when submitting. Your choices help in assigning appropriate reviewers to your submission, and assist the reviewers in evaluating the paper from an appropriate perspective.

The opening of submissions will be announced through the SIGCSE mailing list, social media, and the front page of this website.

Follow the SIGCSE Technical Symposium on Twitter and SIGCSE on Facebook.

By SIGCSE policy, all contributors are required to register, attend, and present a panel. Our full policy (to be posted) has more information.

Questions

If you have questions about anything discussed above, please contact:

Panels and Special Sessions Team

Email: panels@sigcse2021.org

• Christine Alvarado
  University of California, San Diego
• Ben Stephenson
  University of Calgary

Presenting at SIGCSE TS 2021

Important Dates

• January 22 - Submit presentation plans (including a video if desired) through submission form emailed to corresponding authors

How will I be presenting my work? (Panels and Special Sessions)

Panels and special sessions are different from paper presentations in that the live discussion itself is the primary content, rather than the published work. To accommodate this, panels and special session presenters have several options to choose from in how they want to run their session:

• Prerecord the session and make that available through Pathable before the Symposium and then use the live session during the Symposium for longer discussion and Q&A (NOTE: Break out groups will not be possible due to using a Zoom webinar rather than a Zoom meeting. We have to use webinars due to the number of potential attendees.)
• Provide primer material for potential attendees to view ahead of time (e.g. presentations, PDFs) through Pathable, but do not prerecord any content
• Do the entire session live during the Technical Symposium with no early material provided

Note that all panels and special sessions will be recorded and made available on-demand through Pathable for a year following the end of the Symposium.

Panels and special sessions are highly encouraged to discuss with all presenters what makes the most sense for their session. Questions on what might work best can be directed to the Panels and Special Sessions Track Chairs at panels@sigcse2021.org.

Pathable uses embedded Zoom windows in the web application for video presentations, so the experience will be familiar to most presenters. A session chair will moderate the session and we will have technical support available all week to assist as needed.

More information regarding the live sessions, including time slot assignments, will be available in January.

How do I submit my video presentation?

A link to the submission form will be sent to the corresponding authors identified in EasyChair. If you did not receive the email by January 8th or if you have any questions, please email videosubmission@sigcse2021.org.

What rights do I keep to my video?

We are not asking for any rights release on your videos. They remain your work to do with as you please. We only ask, as a courtesy, that you do not post them publicly until one week after the end of the Technical Symposium (March 27, 2021).

Why do you need the presentation so soon (January 22)?

Our goal is to make the prerecorded content of the Technical Symposium available a few weeks before the Symposium starts so that attendees can view materials when convenient to them and so they can better build their schedule for the week of the Symposium. In order to meet that goal, we need to preprocess all the videos as soon as possible to ensure they are ready for the Symposium for reasons including, but not limited to:

• Closed-captioning for all videos (authors do not need to do this on their own - our production company is providing this service)
• Checking format to ensure videos can play properly in Pathable
• Validating the length of videos matches the requirements

Update: We have moved the due date from January 15 to January 22 for all presenters to provide more time for those who wish submit to ITiCSE (https://iticse.acm.org/for-authors/) or who have more than one video submission they need to make. However, we would very much appreciate videos to be sent in as soon as possible so that we can ensure we have enough time to process all the submissions.

Presentation Guidelines

Video presentations must follow these technical guidelines:

• MP4 format encoding
• 1920x1080 (i.e. HD resolution) - If this is not possible for you, please at least record in a 16:9 ratio size
• 30 frames per second (approximately) is preferred to keep file size more reasonable

Please follow the SIGACCESS Guidelines to create a presentation that all attendees can enjoy and learn from. Below, we summarize these guidelines and add a few more:

• Choose a high contrast color scheme that supports color blind readers
• Use more than color coding to communicate information
• Keep text brief
• Keep graphics simple and verbally describe images, animations, videos
• Avoid using a pointer
• Caption videos (NOTE: we will provide a closed-captioning service for you, but there may be points that you want to highlight)
• Speak clearly, use a microphone, face the audience, and use common, understandable terms
• Post your slides early and provide a link them them on the slides (NOTE: we will provide space in Pathable for your slides, but feel free to post them on your own webspace as well)
• Share your contact information

Best Practices for Recording / Remote Presentations

Here are some best practices to consider as you record your video and prepare for your live session:

• Find a quiet room with as little background noise as possible.
• Make sure you are professionally dressed.
• Sit in the center of the camera shot to ensure proper camera framing.
• Make sure your face is well lit by sitting in a room with plenty of light. If you can’t find a well-lit room, place a small lamp in front of you but out of the camera view.
• Do not sit in front of a window. This will cause the camera to adjust for the light, making your face look very dark. Similarly, avoid other light sources behind you.
• Adjust the camera to be level with your eyes. This will produce the best camera angle. If using a laptop, you may need to put your laptop on an elevated surface in order to get the camera level with your eyes.
• Always be aware of what is in the camera shot. Make sure there is nothing sitting in the background that you wouldn’t want viewers to see.
• Use headphones or earbuds to listen to the audio. This helps with the sound quality and ensures you will always be able to hear clearly.
• Keep your microphone muted during the call unless you are speaking.
• When speaking and not wearing a headset or earbuds, keep your speaker volume at the lowest setting while still being able to hear. This helps get rid of echoes coming back through your microphone.
• Use a cabled internet connection when possible. Most connection issues are due to a bad wireless connection.
• Do a test call beforehand to make sure your microphone, speakers and webcam are all working properly.

How do I record my presentation?

An excellent writeup on recording presentations authored by David Ayman Shamma from the SIGCHI community can be found here: https://medium.com/sigchi/a-remote-video-presentation-guide-93957c63aa7a

Using Zoom:

The simplest option is to use Zoom, as it will automatically create the proper file format for you and most of the SIGCSE community is already familiar with the tool.

• Start a meeting with just you as the only participant
• Open your slides and start screen sharing as you normally would in a standard Zoom meeting
• Click “Record” on the main Zoom toolbar at the bottom of the window and select “Record on this Computer”
• Give your presentation, following the best practices for video recordings
• When you are done, stop recording, then stop sharing and end the meeting
• Zoom will automatically convert the video to an .mp4 file format
• Rename the file as instructed and submit via the form emailed to authors from EasyChair

Using OBS:

If you would like to have more control over the presentation, including things such as:

• Smoother transitions between your camera full screen and slides
• Multiple audio/video sources
• Graphic borders around your camera
• Sharing multiple windows at the same time

you may want to try the open source Open Broadcaster Software (OBS) at http://obsproject.com, available for Windows, Mac, and Linux. OBS does require more configuration and setting up than Zoom, but offers a lot of flexibility and options for free. Note that OBS records .mkv files by default. To convert to .mp4, use the “Remux Recordings” option in the File menu.

Using Powerpoint/Keynote:

If you would prefer to not be on camera at all, it is possible to use the “Record Slide Show” option in Powerpoint or Keynote to record a screencast of just your slides.

Converting to .mp4:

If the tool you use does not natively create a .mp4 file for you, you can transcode it for free using Handbrake, found at https://handbrake.fr/. Choose “Fast 1080p30 preset” to generate the proper file format and size.

Closed-Captioning:

Please note that the Technical Symposium is providing a closed-captioning service for all prerecorded videos and live sessions at no cost to you. We are doing this to ensure a standard experience across all aspects of the Symposium.